The Constitutional Crisis is Here
November 15, 2018
Much has been made of the revolving door within the Trump administration. So much, in fact, that The Atlantic recently introduced a “Cabinet Tracker” to take stock of Trump’s ever-evolving cabinet. The current Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, Kirstjen Nielsen, is reportedly set to be replaced soon. Heather Nauert, a State Department spokeswoman whose loyalty to Trump was the source of tension between her and former Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, is the favorite to replace Nikki Haley as the United Nations Ambassador.
There is a current national conversation about an impending constitutional crisis, a perhaps not-too-distant future wherein the levers of constitutional power operate in synchronicity with an ideology, rather than American values. To think of this in future terms, however, is misguided. A crisis exists with this administration and its particular crop of cabinet appointees and judicial nominees, whose adherence to party ideology knows no limit and who come amid the gradual erosion of norms and institutions that have historically served as bulwarks to authoritarian impulses.
This administration’s disregard for norms manifested early on, in the form of Trump’s feud with the press. Last month, Trump referred to the “Fake News Media” as the “true Enemy of the People.” His adversarial relationship with media, particularly media criticism, culminated last week in a White House ban on CNN reporter Jim Acosta. The press holding elected officials accountable to the truth is as American a tradition as any other. In most cases, a working relationship between both parties has been maintained by a system responsive to the freedom of the press.
Now is a different case. Shortly after the administration issued its ban of Acosta, they used a doctored video to support its decision, while continuing attacks on assorted media. These decisions comport with their general stance toward the press, and betray a disregard for both the freedom of the press and those norms which have supported it.
Another crisis point consists in the troubling appointment of Matthew G. Whitaker to acting attorney general. Prior to leading the Justice Department, Whitaker built a reputation as a vocal critic of the Russia investigation, over which he will now directly preside. The likelihood that Whitaker acts on his veritable mandate to undercut the Russia investigation will, by dint of this crisis, go virtually unchecked.
Issues such as these have traditionally been met by an independent judiciary and a strong and functional Congress, both hallmarks of a strong check and balance system. Presently, however, a dysfunctional Congress has proven ill-equipped to keep the administration in check, while the Trump administration has stacked the federal courts with hard-right judges and installed an avowedly partisan Supreme Court justice.
The most marginalized among us stand to suffer the most from this current constitutional crisis. There are many issues in our country which need a meaningful address, and the undermining of foundational norms such as freedom of the press and executive oversight only undermines efforts to do so.
Stay in the know: Sign up for our policy updates, follow us on Twitter, like us on Facebook.
IN THIS SECTION
- Policy Analysis
- Statements & Press
- White House Nominates Rashad Hussain as Ambassador for Religious Freedom
- The Blackhouse Foundation and MPAC’s Hollywood Bureau held their first-ever Television Screenwriting Lab for Black Muslim Writers.
- MPAC CONGRATULATES NUSRAT JAHAN CHOUDHURY ON HISTORIC NOMINATION
- GOP Blocks Coronavirus Bill
- Protect Rights During COVID-19
- Coronavirus Joint Statement
- Senate Passes Coronavirus Relief
- Iran Sanctions In COVID-19
- Historic Senate Relief Package
- Coronavirus Stimulus Problems
- Trump Immigration Suspension is Nothing but Cynical Opportunism
- House Introduces the HEROES Act
- Joint Action to Condemn the Murder of George Floyd
- Toward Pluralism: DA Rosen Must Retract His Whistleblower Complaint
- Supporting of Attorney General Keith Ellison Leading Prosecution for Murder of George Floyd
- Trump’s Executive Order on Census Is Unconstitutional
- MPAC Stands with the NBA Players
- What Muslims Want Heading into the 2020 General Election
- Declare Rittenhouse a Terrorist
- MPAC Firmly Denounces the Failure of the Criminal Justice System for Breonna Taylor
- There Is No Place For Violence in Civil Society
- Updates
- A Win Against White Supremacy
- Mosque Safety & Security
- How We’re Confronting White Supremacy
- Our Work on the Muslim Ban
- 2020 Muslim Voter Guide
- Responding to Covid-19
- Census 2020: What You Need To Know
- Human Security During COVID-19: Our Right
- Quarantine Webinars
- Make an impact in 1, 2, 3...
- Mark Kevin Lloyd is Unfit to Serve in State Department
- SoCal Muslims Show Gratitude To Frontline Workers
- DREAMERS are here to stay!
- A Ramadan Like No Other
- Creating inclusive content for kids & families
- National Muslim Task Force Recommendations for Ramadan During This Pandemic
- Ramadan Mubarak!
- Tale of Two Futures: American Muslim Life After the Election
RELATED STORIES
RELATED MULTIMEDIA
-
2012 Convention Videos
January 7, 2013 -
Al-Marayati interviewed on Viewpoint on Hate Speech
July 29, 2011 -
MPAC Convention Promotional Video
December 6, 2010 -
Dr. Maher Hathout on Elections
October 19, 2010
one-time or monthly donation.