The Battle of Words: Why Terminology Matters
January 22, 2015
Picture by Diego Cambiaso, licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0
Recently, the White House defended its rejection of terms like “radical Islam,” for better and more specific terminology like “violent extremism.” The reason, explained White House spokesman Josh Earnest, is twofold:
1. Accuracy. What is said at the bully pulpit matters, and as such, if something can be properly and specifically addressed, it should. Those who use the power of the bully pulpit responsibly have the power to change public perceptions and attitudes. For example, in 2013, the Associated Press (AP) announced that it would no longer use certain terminology like Islamist when describing “an advocate or supporter of a political movement.” The AP’s decision to modify its guidelines on the use of the highly charged term is part of a broader effort to rid the AP Stylebook of labels that can be vague and misleading on ethnic- and religion-based reporting. The AP announced the change in order to provide a more balanced approach without relying on negative generalizations.
Terminology is key especially when it comes to countering violent extremism (CVE). In light of the White House’s recent announcement that it will convene a “Summit on Countering Violent Extremism” next month, it is all the more imperative that we understand the nuances of words and how they affect our national security and national resiliency. Furthermore, if we use terms like “radical Islam, Islamic jihad, or jihadists” we make enemies out of an entire faith, rather than a minority group of people who practice a perverted ideology.
American Muslims are the most valuable resource in defeating the twisted ideology of extremists who seek to use Islamic justification for their criminal actions. Being accurate with terminology, especially when it comes to the CVE and national security contexts, divorces the perception of religion and terrorism, and focuses our national security resources on any and all potential threats, thereby making our strategy more effective and precise. “All forms of violent extremism would certainly be discussed in the context of the Summit,” stated Earnest. “Including the threat from people who invoke the name of Islam, there are other forms” of violent extremism that will be addressed.
2. Delegitimizing baseless justifications. The second reason Earnest highlighted the importance of terminology is the fact that when we use terms that violent extremists use, we essentially validate their baseless religious claims. Avoiding religious terminology in our efforts to counter violent extremism denies these criminals the religious affiliation they severely lack and so desperately seek. Groups like ISIS and Al-Qaeda and their affiliates justify their criminal actions through distorted justifications of Islamic teachings. Taking away these religious labels in our national conversations is a strategic move in fighting these groups, not just with military might, but with powerful counter-messaging. The worst thing we can do is unknowingly find ourselves in a situation where we are legitimizing illegitimate justifications for acts of violence.
MPAC seeks to clear ambiguity by defining appropriate terminology in a more substantive manner through our fellowship program with a full policy report to be released later this year. Using accurate terminology will not only empower and embolden valuable resources in the partnership to counter violent extremism, it furthers America’s strategic interests in securing our nation while being mindful of building a resilient and cohesive citizenry.
We look forward to the White House including the importance of terminology as part of its summit on CVE next month. The conversation around Countering Violent Extremism (CVE) is taking place amongst policy-makers and the media. American Muslims must be an integral part of this conversation. Our approach at MPAC has been clear since day one on this topic: American Muslims must be seen as partners, not suspects.
IN THIS SECTION
- Policy Analysis
- Statements & Press
- White House Nominates Rashad Hussain as Ambassador for Religious Freedom
- The Blackhouse Foundation and MPAC’s Hollywood Bureau held their first-ever Television Screenwriting Lab for Black Muslim Writers.
- MPAC CONGRATULATES NUSRAT JAHAN CHOUDHURY ON HISTORIC NOMINATION
- GOP Blocks Coronavirus Bill
- Protect Rights During COVID-19
- Coronavirus Joint Statement
- Senate Passes Coronavirus Relief
- Iran Sanctions In COVID-19
- Historic Senate Relief Package
- Coronavirus Stimulus Problems
- Trump Immigration Suspension is Nothing but Cynical Opportunism
- House Introduces the HEROES Act
- Joint Action to Condemn the Murder of George Floyd
- Toward Pluralism: DA Rosen Must Retract His Whistleblower Complaint
- Supporting of Attorney General Keith Ellison Leading Prosecution for Murder of George Floyd
- Trump’s Executive Order on Census Is Unconstitutional
- MPAC Stands with the NBA Players
- What Muslims Want Heading into the 2020 General Election
- Declare Rittenhouse a Terrorist
- MPAC Firmly Denounces the Failure of the Criminal Justice System for Breonna Taylor
- There Is No Place For Violence in Civil Society
- Updates
- A Win Against White Supremacy
- Mosque Safety & Security
- How We’re Confronting White Supremacy
- Our Work on the Muslim Ban
- 2020 Muslim Voter Guide
- Responding to Covid-19
- Census 2020: What You Need To Know
- Human Security During COVID-19: Our Right
- Quarantine Webinars
- Make an impact in 1, 2, 3...
- Mark Kevin Lloyd is Unfit to Serve in State Department
- SoCal Muslims Show Gratitude To Frontline Workers
- DREAMERS are here to stay!
- A Ramadan Like No Other
- Creating inclusive content for kids & families
- National Muslim Task Force Recommendations for Ramadan During This Pandemic
- Ramadan Mubarak!
- Tale of Two Futures: American Muslim Life After the Election
RELATED STORIES
-
New DoJ Guidance Unacceptable
December 11, 2014 -
Ferguson: Confronting "A Nation of Cowards"
November 26, 2014 -
Jerusalem: More Divided Than Ever
November 21, 2014 -
114th Congress: Deliver or Disappoint?
November 13, 2014
RELATED MULTIMEDIA
-
Dr. Maher Hathout on Elections
October 19, 2010 -
9/11 Interfaith Peace Vigil
September 11, 2010 -
Khutba on Islamophobia
September 10, 2010 -
Iraq After Seven Years
August 31, 2010
one-time or monthly donation.